[DEFEATED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Moderators: Salem, Delegate

Post Reply
User avatar
LiberzanEmpire
Posts: 292
Joined: 20 Jun 2023, 03:31
Nation: Liberza
Discord: liberza
Location: Planet Earth (Maybe)

[DEFEATED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Post by LiberzanEmpire »

The General Assembly

Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

A resolution to improve worldwide human and civil rights.

Category: Civil Righta | Strength: Strong | Proposed by: The Ice States
Whereas ethnic and cultural discrimination occurs in many member nations, yet is inherently unjust such that member nations have a duty both to protect their citizens against, and themselves refrain from, such discrimination; and

Whereas the repeal of "The Charter of Civil Rights" has left an ominous silence regarding protections against ethnic and cultural discrimination;

The World Assembly enacts as follows.

Definition: For the purposes of this resolution, a "protected characteristic" is any characteristic such as skin colour, nationality and language which is subject to discrimination as a result of its connection to an individual's culture, ethnicity or race. Culture, ethnicity and race are themselves protected characteristics.

Services: No member nation, or entity therein, may withhold, delay, or segregate any service, right or privilege, including employment and remuneration as well as sale of goods and property, from an individual on the grounds of any real or perceived protected characteristic possessed or lacked by that individual. The following exceptions apply to this provision, although nothing in the said exceptions preclude exempted conditions from being an unlawful form of discrimination based on another real or perceived protected characteristic.

Section 2 shall not prohibit a service, right, policy, or privilege clearly related to a protected characteristic, where such a requirement is strictly necessary to mitigate harms towards persons holding a particular protected characteristic without causing similar or worse harms to those lacking it, from being conditional on the recipient's holding of that protected characteristic.

Section 2 also shall not prohibit an entity from requiring those selected to conduct some task to hold a particular protected characteristic, if and only if that entity can demonstrate clear and convincing objective evidence that both (a) the task is clearly related to the said protected characteristic, and (b) that protected characteristic is strictly necessary to effectively carry out the relevant tasks if selected. For roles with a language requirement, no person may be discriminated against on the grounds that their language fluency is learnt and not their native language.

Segregation: Systematic or otherwise intentional and statistically disproportionate violence perpetrated against a group, forceful isolation or internment of a group in designated areas, removal of a group from designated areas, or the forceful institution of population controls on a group are recognised as acts of genocide. The segregation of a population based on any real or perceived protected characteristic, regardless of whether such segregation is enforced by a state, is universally prohibited under World Assembly jurisdiction.

Classification: Every member nation is to consider protected characteristics to be arbitrary and reductive, and accordingly enforce laws against hate crime, violence, and other discrimination on the grounds of real or perceived protected characteristics as with any other arbitrary, reductive characteristic. No part of this resolution should be interpreted as preventing member nations from jointly or severally enacting further legislation to protect against discrimination on the grounds of any real or perceived protected characteristic. Terms in the singular are to be interpreted as including the plural thereof, absent clarification otherwise.

Co-authors: Simone Republic, Wallenburg
Link to the discussion on the NS Forums

ForAgainstAbstain
##FOR####AGAINST####ABSTAIN##


Please vote and discuss below. Feel free to make additional posts in discussion.
Last edited by LiberzanEmpire on 07 Mar 2024, 10:55, edited 2 times in total.
Sometimes, I dream about bacon

I wonder how TRR feels about having had a 13 year old iPad kid be one of their officers ;P
User avatar
Salem
Posts: 395
Joined: 10 Jun 2021, 17:26
Nation: Dakota
Discord: dakadak
Location: Among the Cacti

Re: [QUEUED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Post by Salem »

Nay
he/him
frattastan wrote: All the raiders died on first night, that's what matters.
guy wrote: Yeah makes sense. Just go to Koth
Fuck you’re a weird unit sometimes
But yeah shit in peace.
User avatar
Bormiar
Posts: 473
Joined: 08 Apr 2019, 02:17
Nation: Bormiar

Re: [QUEUED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Post by Bormiar »

This proposal is unenforceable. Against.
The Second Coming is nigh upon us.
User avatar
LiberzanEmpire
Posts: 292
Joined: 20 Jun 2023, 03:31
Nation: Liberza
Discord: liberza
Location: Planet Earth (Maybe)

Re: [QUEUED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Post by LiberzanEmpire »

Against, I don’t like equality
Sometimes, I dream about bacon

I wonder how TRR feels about having had a 13 year old iPad kid be one of their officers ;P
User avatar
Minskiev
Posts: 873
Joined: 13 May 2020, 18:14
Nation: Minskiev
Discord: walrus#8689
Location: the arctic

Re: [QUEUED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Post by Minskiev »

Interesting how the formatting has changed. Of course, this still heavily relies on stuff like "clear and convincing," "objective," "effectively," "strictly necessary" since that's. y'know. An inherent problem of the GA, not being able to have full objectivity. So they just throw it everywhere, fair enough.

I think it's pretty decently thorough although the exceptions could maybe elaborate more. I'm sure there are reasons for their existence, but it doesn't really try to justify itself much.

For, regardless.
Minskiev/Walrus. Former Delegate of the Rejected Realms, 3x Officer. 11x WA author. Join the RRA here.
User avatar
Salem
Posts: 395
Joined: 10 Jun 2021, 17:26
Nation: Dakota
Discord: dakadak
Location: Among the Cacti

Re: [QUEUED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Post by Salem »

Voted against with the current vote count being 3 against and 1 for.
he/him
frattastan wrote: All the raiders died on first night, that's what matters.
guy wrote: Yeah makes sense. Just go to Koth
Fuck you’re a weird unit sometimes
But yeah shit in peace.
User avatar
Ambrosia
Posts: 187
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 00:00
Nation: Ambroscus
Discord: valtarre

Re: [QUEUED] Promoting Ethnic And Cultural Equality

Post by Ambrosia »

AGAINST, it's not a repeal.
Post Reply

Return to “General Assembly”