Amending 7F of the constitution?

A forum containing past Assembly discussions.

Moderator: Speaker

Locked
User avatar
Opressed Ones
Posts: 385
Joined: 31 Mar 2014, 00:00

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Opressed Ones »

Article 7F:
F: In the case there is more than one Officer position vacant, and at the end of the challenge period for any vacancy the number of candidates for all vacant positions exceeds the number of vacancies, one election shall be held for all vacant positions. As many candidates shall be elected as there are vacancies. Each citizen shall be eligible to cast as many votes as there are vacancies.
The last sentence doesn't fit our intended voting system and might have to be removed.
The officer positions will all be vacated on the 1st of December.
We'll get a problem if there are more candidates than needed then
User avatar
Guy
Posts: 5143
Joined: 21 Oct 2010, 00:00
Location: Melbourne

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Guy »

You still cast one vote. You get multiple preferences.
User avatar
Opressed Ones
Posts: 385
Joined: 31 Mar 2014, 00:00

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Opressed Ones »

Each citizen shall be eligible to cast as many votes as there are vacancies.
Look- that is the problematic sentence.
I see two possible interpretations:
1. Ranking all candidates is seen as one vote(not my interpretation):
Clearly not fitting into the new voting system.
2.Every candidate ranked is seen as one vote:
Neither fitting into the new voting system, in the new voting system, you have as many votes as there are candidates, not vacancies.
User avatar
Ryno
Posts: 958
Joined: 02 Nov 2013, 00:00

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Ryno »

I can see how that sentence looks silly and is a stretch to fit our system.

Would you prefer something like this?

Each citizen shall be eligible to cast a vote that will allow all vacant positions to be filled.
Who am I? Ryno, protector of regions, great unicorn soldier, fighter for NS purity, and bringer of greatness to TRR.
#notmywords
User avatar
frattastan
Posts: 10318
Joined: 02 Jan 2011, 00:00
Discord: frattastan#2205
Location: Soft Underbelly of Europe

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by frattastan »

Opressed Ones wrote:Neither fitting into the new voting system, in the new voting system, you have as many votes as there are candidates
If that was true I could give a candidate multiple preferences (it could be both my first and second favourite), or give my first preference to multiple candidates.

The vote is one.
In this world there are two kinds of people: those with loaded guns and those who dig. I dig.
User avatar
Opressed Ones
Posts: 385
Joined: 31 Mar 2014, 00:00

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Opressed Ones »

frattastan wrote:
07 Nov 2014, 11:50
Opressed Ones wrote:Neither fitting into the new voting system, in the new voting system, you have as many votes as there are candidates
If that was true I could give a candidate multiple preferences (it could be both my first and second favourite), or give my first preference to multiple candidates.

The vote is one.
You got a point, however, like I stated earlier, this doesn't solve the problem.
If I see 5 candidates, and 4 vacancies I have to allow you 4 votes. The sentence doesn't fit.
User avatar
Guy
Posts: 5143
Joined: 21 Oct 2010, 00:00
Location: Melbourne

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Guy »

Yeah, let's just delete that sentence.
User avatar
Opressed Ones
Posts: 385
Joined: 31 Mar 2014, 00:00

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Opressed Ones »

Please tell us if you don't like the idea of deleting the last sentence.
User avatar
frattastan
Posts: 10318
Joined: 02 Jan 2011, 00:00
Discord: frattastan#2205
Location: Soft Underbelly of Europe

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by frattastan »

Agreed, that would fix it.
In this world there are two kinds of people: those with loaded guns and those who dig. I dig.
User avatar
Opressed Ones
Posts: 385
Joined: 31 Mar 2014, 00:00

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Opressed Ones »

No more answers- I might put this to vote soon.
User avatar
Ryno
Posts: 958
Joined: 02 Nov 2013, 00:00

Amending 7F of the constitution?

Post by Ryno »

Opressed Ones wrote:
11 Nov 2014, 22:04
No more answers- I might put this to vote soon.
Sounds good to me.
Who am I? Ryno, protector of regions, great unicorn soldier, fighter for NS purity, and bringer of greatness to TRR.
#notmywords
Locked

Return to “Discussion”